Readify

Washington Monument

The Plot Against America

The Washington Monument is a central stop on the Roth family's tour of Washington, D.C., but its significance reaches beyond its height and history. As guide Verlin M. Taylor presents it as a national landmark, Herman Roth uses the visit to voice his opposition to Charles A. Lindbergh; Bess Roth urges him to keep quiet. The monument's public grandeur thus becomes the setting for a private family dispute about who can speak freely in America, and its view across the reflecting pool toward the Lincoln Memorial ends the day's sightseeing with the Roths feeling, in the narrator's words, expelled from the patriotic scene.

Setting and the guided tour

Verlin M. Taylor proposes the Washington Monument as the first major stop after lunch, before a drive down the Mall to the Lincoln Memorial. He presents Washington and Lincoln as the nation's two greatest presidents and makes the itinerary itself a lesson in national history. His account moves from George Washington's role in choosing the capital's site and making it the permanent seat of government to John Adams's arrival at the White House in 1800. Even an object inside the White House—a celery glass owned by John and Abigail Adams—becomes part of the guide's appeal to historical detail.

At the monument, Taylor gives the family figures that make its scale tangible: it rises 555 feet and five and one-eighth inches above ground, then the tallest masonry structure in the world. An electric elevator reaches the top in one and a quarter minutes; the alternative is a winding staircase of 893 steps. From the summit, he says, the view extends for fifteen to twenty miles. The facts turn the monument into both a structure to be measured and a vantage point from which the capital can be surveyed.

The tour also includes the monument's recent upkeep. Taylor explains that it was cleaned for the first time only a few years earlier, using water mixed with sand and steel-bristled brushes. The work took five months and cost $100,000. Herman asks whether it happened under Franklin D. Roosevelt, and Taylor believes it did. This exchange brings the monument's maintenance into the family's political present: even a public works detail prompts Herman to think about the administration and the country that have replaced it.

A national monument and a political disagreement

Herman's criticism of Lindbergh breaks into the carefully managed tour. After Taylor describes the monument, Herman complains that people would rather have an airmail pilot running the country than recognize the work done under Roosevelt. Taylor listens courteously but does not answer. His silence contrasts with the guide's fluent command of dates, dimensions, and cleaning methods; the tour can accommodate sharp political disagreement without resolving it.

When the family enters the monument, Taylor remains outside. Bess takes her husband's hand and whispers that he must not talk that way about Lindbergh. Herman replies that he is speaking at the Washington Monument, not in Berlin, and points to Taylor's official credentials as reassurance that the family is in a public, legitimate setting. But the location does not make Bess feel safe. Other visitors can overhear them, and she is distressed by the bluntness of his remarks. The landmark's openness—the public space in which citizens gather and look outward—does not prevent political speech from feeling dangerous within the family.

The elevator ride briefly turns the monument into a moving social space. Around twenty adults and children enter, filling it about halfway. As the car rises through its iron-pillared housing, Herman asks the other families where they are from; one answers Maine, while the Roths are from New Jersey. The ascent lasts only the same one and a quarter minutes Taylor has cited, yet Herman uses that short interval to address family after family. The monumental view is not the only way the place makes the country visible: in the elevator, the country appears as strangers answering a question about where they belong.

The monument in the family's memory

After the tour inside, Taylor asks Sandy and Philip to describe what they saw from the windows five hundred feet up. He then leads them on a quick walk around the exterior, recounting the monument's fitful construction. The family photographs preserve another kind of record: Taylor takes pictures of them with their Brownie box camera, and Herman insists—despite Taylor's objections—on a photograph of the guide with Bess, Sandy, and Philip, using the Washington Monument as the background. The guide who has narrated the landmark is thus placed inside the family's own image of the visit.

That shared photograph does not settle the tensions the tour has exposed. The monument is at once an educational stop, a public workplace of historical memory, and the backdrop to a family trying to negotiate what may be said aloud. Herman's invocation of Roosevelt and his complaint about Lindbergh interrupt Taylor's polished account, while Bess's warnings register the cost she fears in speaking so openly. The scene lets the disagreement remain visible rather than converting the landmark into a simple emblem of agreement or national unity.

Across the reflecting pool

The next stop, the Lincoln Memorial, sharpens the Washington Monument's role in the sequence. After the family returns from the monument, Taylor drives them down the Mall and warns them to prepare to be overwhelmed by the memorial. There, the narrator sees Lincoln's face as an amalgamation of the face of God and the face of America; Herman responds by recalling that Lincoln was shot. The two landmarks therefore meet in a sequence of grandeur and political vulnerability: the nation's monumental image is accompanied by reminders of the leaders who shaped it and of violence done to them.

After leaving the Lincoln Memorial, the family gathers on its top step. The Washington Monument stands half a mile away at the far end of the reflecting pool, beyond the terraced approach; elm trees surround the view. The narrator describes the panorama as a patriotic paradise, but the family stands huddled together there, “the family expelled.” The monument is not the site of that final gathering, yet its conspicuous presence across the water helps define the scene. A landscape arranged to display the capital's beauty and national inheritance becomes, for the Roths, an image of exclusion: they can see the patriotic ideal, but do not feel at home within it.